Former minister Alan Milburn urged large employers this week to give all unsuccessful job applicants under 25 “meaningful feedback,” a recommendation aimed at cutting the share of young people not in employment, education or training from 13% to about 5% by 2036.
The proposal sits in Milburn’s major review into so-called Neets, published this week and covered by BBC News. Its provisions apply mainly to England, with a recommendation that Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland adapt the principles to their own systems.
“It can really take hours and hours, so it just feels even worse to not even have that be recognised,” Jessica Anderson, 21, from Swindon, told BBC News.
Yugraj Samrai, 23, from Coventry, said he has submitted hundreds of applications since graduating with a marketing degree in July. “I understand there are very few graduate jobs available, but at least give me a response to say whether I’ll progress onto the next stage or not,” he told BBC News. He hears nothing back 30% to 40% of the time, which makes him “feel like a statistic, not a person.”
Ffion Johns, 24, from Llanelli, said she sent 70 applications before securing an interview in September after being unemployed since June. “With most of these roles I’m not getting a rejection. I’m just not hearing anything, which can be quite frustrating,” she told BBC News. She said she has also been ghosted after interviews.
Research by Robert Walters last year found 86% of UK job hunters said their applications had been ignored with no response at all from the hiring organisation.
Employers say they are being flooded with applications in a highly competitive market and that responding to all of them is difficult. Meg Burton, a career coach based in Leeds, said firms should at minimum inform applicants when they are unsuccessful and that AI could help achieve this. Candidates who reach interview stage should receive proper feedback, she told BBC News. “It doesn’t have to be hugely detailed, it’s just some pointers on why they were unsuccessful and what they can learn from that experience going forward,” she said.
Ellie McCrone, 20, from Northampton, acknowledged the concern that a flood of rejections could be demoralising but said hearing back is still better. “If you are applying for hundreds of jobs and never getting anything, I think something is going wrong… You can’t fix something unless you know what the problem is,” she told BBC News.
Burton advised applicants to tailor their CV to each job and avoid submitting “hundreds and hundreds of applications” that all look the same. “Not hearing back doesn’t mean you aren’t a great candidate. Put it down to experience and move on,” she told BBC News.
Keep reading